Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ray Rothfeldt's avatar

A very good article, but you missed on the most important (and sickening) aspect of this speech. There wasn't a mention of the actual state of the Union. Instead, we got an unbridled campaign stemwinder. Our Constitution doesn't require the State of the Union be a speech and for decades, presidents just sent Congress a letter describing how the Union was faring. It's probably time to return to that tradition.

Expand full comment
Jeff Mockensturm's avatar

He started lying at around 9:15 pm and by my watch didn't stop until around 10:30. There were so many whoppers he could open a Burger King franchise. But these aren't "lies" like Trump tells (which are actually exaggerations or partially, mostly or completely true) but bald-faced opposite-of-truth lies. Like the "15 million NEW jobs created" (we're STILL below the number of jobs pre-Covid). Or "I cut ONE TRILLION DOLLARS from the deficit in my first year!" (He signed the $1.9 Trillion America Rescue Plan supplemental in March 2021 and since his FIRST budget to Congress in 2022 didn't include THAT additional spending, he claims he CUT spending - Good Lord, what a whopper!). And when you add in the $800B extra spent on the ironically named Inflation Reduction Act, he set inflation on fire.

While SOTUs have become more "campaign speeches" in the modern era (since Clinton, but a brief hiatus when GWB was president), this speech dropped all pretense. Perhaps it is because his opponent for reelection is already known, but I wouldn't have expected much different even if Trump hadn't sewn up the nomination. It's a disappointment because the SOTU is constitutionally mandated and is supposed to present the entirety of government to the American people - not serve as a campaign event.

Expand full comment
3 more comments...

No posts