Discussion about this post

User's avatar
chad's avatar

Spot on David. I have made this same rant with many, and even some Christians will say, "but we need the government to....", or, "we must have compassion." Sorry, charity through government is not compassionate to anyone. Good article!

Expand full comment
Bennie's avatar

I have found that when I am arguing with a “liberal” and manage to rhetorically box him into a corner, he will confide that the welfare state is not so much about social justice as it is about buying off society’s lower achievers. Those who finish last in the Game of Life will not necessarily be good sports about it.

Speaking as a libertarian who feels guilty about participating in a city rec department softball league (Socialist Softball!), I am willing to entertain the idea of a guaranteed minimum income as a replacement for welfare and unemployment benefit bureaucracies.

Continuing the “game” analogy, think of it as a consolation prize (“Johnny, what do we have for our departing contestants?”).

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts