8 Comments
User's avatar
David Graf's avatar

I had family living in Austin and renting. One important difference compared to NYC is that Manhattan has an area of 23 square miles compared to 320 square miles in Austin. There's a lot more area to expand and build new housing. That's not the case there where building new housing means that you would have to tear down something including rent subsidized apartments. If you include all of NYC, you get around 304 square miles which is comparable to Austin but with eight to nine times the number of people. Why wouldn't builders especially in Manhattan go for those buyers/renters who would give them the most profit instead of marketing to those less well off?

Peter Venetoklis's avatar

There are countless 4, 5, and 6 story buildings that, but for government, could and would become 12 story buildings. There are tens of thousands of empty apartments that aren't worth being brought up to current codes, because the owners would never recoup the cost due to both excessive requirements and rent limits. There are entire neighborhoods that used to be nonresidential that could be converted if government got out of the way.

There is also the fact that NYC is not just Manhattan. Get government out of the way, and plenty of housing stock will come on the market.

Yes, that entails eliminating rent controlled units, perhaps as they come on the market when the existing renters move on. But the current system doesn't work. Why argue against change?

Mamdani's way would double down on what doesn't work, but I figure he doesn't care. He's a "seize the means of production" socialist, and if given enough rope would seize private housing stock.

David Graf's avatar

You are right in so much of your comment. I see your points. Thanks for enlightening me and I am not being sarcastic when I say that. It's a shame that Mamdani will just double down on what already doesn't work.

chad's avatar

The only issue I see with using Austin as an example is that it’s a $h17h0l3. It’s the San Francisco of Texas, minus the cost.

Peter Venetoklis's avatar

People do choose to live there. How they choose to live? Up to them.

Sean Dullaghan's avatar

Then they ought to be giving away houses with the purchase of a Canes jersey in NC, with the rate they are slapping up certified Generican plain Jane cheese boxes on the freshly plowed under farmland and forests here.

Kathryn DeFea's avatar

I'm constantly amazed by how naive the progressives are about economics. I got into a debate about this very topic with an old college friend who responded to my comment about excessive government regulation with the retort that I don't object to Prop 13 limitations on property tax increases. Sigh. How does he not understand that limiting the amount the government can tax you for property you already own is not the same as the government limiting how much a property owner can charge to rent their property?

Peter Venetoklis's avatar

A lot of it is ego-driven, and the rest is cognitive dissonance covering up their greed and envy. It's very easy to say "take from someone else" by pretending that "someone else" has more than they "need."